Home · Spiritual corner

From behind the tree: three questions for those who say "Rama struck from hiding too"

The killing of Vali is the hardest episode in the Ramayana. Tradition did not hide Vali's protest; it recorded it in full. What Rama did after that single arrow is told far less often.

Ashwini Kumar Srivastava ·

Chapter 14 · A Part of MePunishmentdigitalsampatti.com

"Rama also shot Vali from behind a tree." You hear this most often from people who strike others in the back. Chapter 14 of A Part of Me tests that line, and admits frankly that this is the hardest episode in the book's second part.

Two brothers and a sealed cave

Vali, king of Kishkindha, and his younger brother Sugriva were once devoted to each other. One day a demon named Mayavi challenged Vali and fled into a cave. Vali followed, telling Sugriva to wait at the mouth. A year later blood flowed out of the cave and cries echoed from inside, and Sugriva believed his brother was dead. In fear he sealed the cave with a boulder and went home, where the ministers made him king.

But Vali was alive. When he returned, he concluded that Sugriva had left him to die out of greed for the throne. Sugriva begged forgiveness, but Vali would not listen. He drove Sugriva out and took Sugriva's wife, Ruma, for himself.

The arrow, and Vali's question

On Mount Rishyamuka, Rama and Sugriva became allies, with fire as witness. Rama promised to restore Sugriva's kingdom and his wife. The brothers fought, and when Sugriva began to tire, Rama shot from behind a tree. Vali fell.

Dying, Vali asked the question that is still asked today. In Tulsidas's words: you came to protect dharma, yet you killed me like a hunter? In Valmiki the protest is longer: I was fighting someone else, not you; what wrong had I done you?

The book stresses one point: tradition did not hide Vali's question. Both Valmiki and Tulsidas recorded it with full force.

Rama's answer

Rama's main answer was about dharma: you took your younger brother's wife while he was alive. In Valmiki, Rama also says he is punishing wrongdoing as the representative of King Bharata, and that he could not break his word to Sugriva. Valmiki records one more argument, that Vali was a vanara and kings may hunt animals from cover. The book acknowledges that many readers find this hard, and does not lean on it.

The part that is rarely told

Hearing Rama, Vali admitted his wrong and asked forgiveness. Then, in Tulsidas, Rama placed his hand on Vali's head and offered to keep him alive. The one he had just punished, Rama was ready to restore. Vali declined: to die with Rama before his eyes was a chance that might never come again.

Vali's last worry was his son Angada. Rama took the boy's hand. Valmiki says he also comforted the grieving Tara. Sugriva became king, but Angada was made crown prince, so the next king would be Vali's own son. Rama took nothing from Kishkindha for himself.

The book's honest test

The book tests every harsh episode against four measures: the cause, how long the harshness lasted, self-interest, and sequence. Rama passes three here: the cause was a wrong done to a woman, the enmity ended at once, and he took nothing. On the fourth, sequence, a question remains: there was no warning and no dialogue. Tradition offers answers, that this was punishment rather than combat, and that Vali had already rejected both Sugriva's apology and Tara's advice to make peace. Still, the book says, the episode never becomes fully comfortable, and perhaps it should not.

A question for today

The chapter's line is direct. Ask anyone who says "Rama struck from hiding too": did you take the hand of the son of the person you brought down? Did you return his kingdom to his own family? Did you answer his question? This article is drawn from Chapter 14 of the book, based on the Valmiki Ramayana (Kishkindha Kanda, cantos 9 to 25) and the Kishkindha Kanda of the Ramcharitmanas.

This article is drawn from Chapter 14 of A Part of Me. Figures and events in the book are as of October 2026.